Loomio

Pay for Ministers of Parliment

DU Maelwryth Public Seen by 142

On the 26th of February 2015 the Remuneration Authority (http://remauthority.govt.nz/) gave MP's a raise of between $8200-23,400 per annum.

It also noted that: "based on current movements in remuneration for top-level executive positions, the gap between market remuneration and the remuneration of senior members of the Executive and Parliament is increasing...the Authority continues to have concerns at the widening gap between the remuneration of Ministers and the chief executives and staff reporting to them and will continue to review the gap annually."

DU

Poll Created Fri 27 Feb 2015 2:45AM

Tie MP's wages to the media wage of the country. Closed Mon 2 Mar 2015 2:05AM

Outcome
by Maelwryth Tue 25 Apr 2017 5:23AM

8 people agreed with the proposal, 2 abstained, 1 disagreed, and 3 blocked the proposal. The blocks have it.

The decision is not to tie MP's wages to the median wage of the country as the question is wrong in some way.

The median income of wage earners and salaries was roughly $45,000 a year in 2014.
Agreeing would mean you think the Remuneration Authority should base MP salary on the median wage.

Dis-agreeing means you don't think the Remuneration Authority should base MP salary on the median wage.

Blocking means you believe the question to be wrong in some way.

Abstaining means you cannot decide either way for any reason.

Results

Results Option % of points Voters
Agree 57.1% 8 DU IK JT CS TH IA ES C
Abstain 14.3% 2 P NA
Disagree 7.1% 1 BR
Block 21.4% 3 CE PB JD
Undecided 0% 598 MS SM T MP JA PB SM KG VC TF P AP MB ISI AP MM SG JT DG AR

14 of 612 people have participated (2%)

DU

Grant Keinzley
Agree
Fri 27 Feb 2015 2:51AM

I think the recent parliament pay increase is simply outrageous. I fully support this proposal.

P

pilotfever
Agree
Fri 27 Feb 2015 2:56AM

It is difficult for those too wealthy to appreciate the plight of the less wealthy.

P

pilotfever
Block
Fri 27 Feb 2015 3:23AM

@kimdotcom Like in a startup, I think investment and any wages paid must reflect the value the MP brings to the party, and particularly, the strategic value in their ideas.

P

pilotfever
Abstain
Fri 27 Feb 2015 3:39AM

I have reservations about this proposal, and would prefer to engage in discussion before placing a vote.

PB

Peter Baxter
Block
Fri 27 Feb 2015 4:07AM

The proposed level is too low, but agree the principle that it should be tied to a more realistic level. Tying to "top executives" (a fantasy compared with their median capability level) makes MP's part of the growing problem of the "wage gap"

BR

Blair Robson
Disagree
Fri 27 Feb 2015 5:01PM

I believe that the job of an MP particularly a minister should be well remunerated...TBH I wouldnt be against much higher pay packages....They do an important job. All our BEST people are in private sectors roles and this is why.

IK

Ian Kiddle
Agree
Fri 27 Feb 2015 6:20PM

I agree as this would be a type of performance based reward for MP's. Raise your own pay by raising the living standards of all NZ'ers

CE

Colin England
Block
Fri 27 Feb 2015 6:43PM

I think we should be setting politicians pay via referendum.

JD

John Davenport
Block
Sat 28 Feb 2015 2:16AM

MPs jobs are far too important. The impact on our lives through legislation they pass is far reaching. Their remuneration needs to reflect this.

Load More