Loomio

GST

TH Thomas Henry Public Seen by 71

get rid of the GST so that the low income families can put food on the Tables

DU

Damon Horrell Mon 14 Jul 2014 7:37AM

You'll get my vote. GST is a tax on the poor. Low-income families spend all of their income and hence pay more GST proportionally than high-income families who can save and/or spend on things that don't attract GST (like overseas trips and investment properties).

DU

fuck you assholes Mon 14 Jul 2014 7:45AM

I think we should lower it as a transitional step.

WV

Wade Vuglar Mon 14 Jul 2014 6:50PM

Yep. Remove GST entirely. It is a poor tax. Replacee i5 with a Financial Transaction Tax at a tenth of a percent,

DD

Dennis Dorney Tue 15 Jul 2014 12:17AM

It may be necessary to lower GST in quite quick stages (@reidalexanderwicks) because of the impact it has on supposed 'inflation'.. Other than that there is no good to be said about a GST. It is a flat rate tax which is no good at all for the poor. I also agree with @wadevuglar.

MW

Marc Whinery Tue 15 Jul 2014 8:27AM

The "good thing" about GST is that it generates tax income from visitors. Most places without a GST still have GST on "tourist" things, like hotel rooms and rental cars.

DU

fuck you assholes Tue 15 Jul 2014 10:50AM

@marcwhinery Good point, especially considering how much we like to boast about our tourism industry.

JC

Josh Chapman Thu 17 Jul 2014 1:53AM

I definitely agree with a GST reduction or removal. Keep GST on manufactured products and services, but I think that most things available in the supermarket should be GST-free (with the exclusion of unhealthy and "treat" foods). Put an additional "trans-fat tax" on takeaways and over-processed foods (not processed like milk/bread/butter). We have excise taxes on tobacco and alcohol (that keep increasing every year), so i think it's very hypocritical to not have one that includes high salt & fat-laden food.

DU

Nigel McNie Fri 25 Jul 2014 4:31AM

Having GST on some good but not others is a huge administration nightmare which will cost more than it ever saves.

Whether you raise it, lower it, or keep it the same - just don't make it inconsistent. It might feel "right" to have sugary/fatty foods cost more, but the admin is a disaster. Deal with that problem another way.