Switching Petition Platforms
Tristan Copley Smith
Public
Seen by 106
The #WeAreTwitter petition is currently hosted on the Action Network platform. Change.org is an alternative platform interested in hosting our petition for the campaign's re-launch on Monday (tomorrow).
Here are the pros and cons, as highlighted in the #communications channel on Slack:
Pros for moving to Change.org:
- It is a better known platform with larger community (12m in UK alone)
- They have offered to support our campaign in newsletters emails to their community in UK an look into other countries as well
- There have been issues with the Action Network platform including language support, misleading signature goals, smaller user community
Cons for moving to Change.org:
- Current petition signees will need to re-sign, we may loose some
- Unlike Action Network, Change.org is for-profit and controversial among some activists (see http://bit.ly/2f0Ep8g)
- They use cookies and tracking for advertisements
Amelia Rose Khan
Sun 30 Oct 2016 6:39PM
I don't see how change.org is better then AN except for wider outreach help. The outreach help doesn't give me enough to say change.org is better.
Bernardo Parrella
Sun 30 Oct 2016 6:53PM
even if a bit risky, as others pointed out, it's certainly worth switching -- but we must ensure that it can be translated in as many languages as possible (and collect email addresses)
Tom McDonough
Sun 30 Oct 2016 7:07PM
The database of petition signers is our most important asset and must remain independent.
I don't know the backend of either Change or ActionNetwork but keeping the database where it is seems best.
mai ishikawa sutton
Sun 30 Oct 2016 7:44PM
It doesn't seem like the reasons for leaving AN is outweighed by the benefits of Change, especially given its drawbacks re: privacy, being for-profit, lack of ability to control the post-signing page, and questionable lack of language support.
Katharina Simon Sun 30 Oct 2016 11:27AM
Ok then lets do that
Johnny Haeusler Sun 30 Oct 2016 3:31PM
I will cross post this: Who can set up a test petition on change.org to see a) if they allow international campaigns with different languages and b) if we have control over the data generated?
Kirsten Lambertsen Sun 30 Oct 2016 4:01PM
I'm also curious about the re-signing bit. Is that really necessary? Would a new, differently worded petition cancel out our previous petition?
Bernardo Parrella Sun 30 Oct 2016 8:23PM
we are discussing this on slack right now: https://buytwitter.slack.com/messages/petition/ (we'd consolidate all discussion topics in only one place, no? slack seems better for this...even if there is the "loomio bot")
Danny Spitzberg Mon 31 Oct 2016 5:24AM
I'm generally for whatever we can to do amplify our efforts and draw attention to the petition. Also, I see a lot of renewed enthusiasm around this move!
So, to clarify the opportunity and channel our energy, I drafted a 1-page doc with my best shot at summarizing our campaign goals, strategies, tactics, and timeline/escalation – check it out and make comments/edits at https://docs.google.com/document/d/1vy-gOGDLDeRLkw48wraNoB8sOZlHXtz1NI9C5YhNfR4/edit.
Now if we believe 100,000 signatures is enough (as @mairasutton commented) to "open doors" to more press coverage and to Twitter (as @johnnyhaeusler said), then we can evaluate our strategies, see how they add up (or not), and coordinate our efforts.
One last thing: 1,529 people already signed one petition. As @ntnsndr has said, we absolutely must send an honest, motivating invitation to these individuals to add their name a second time.
Poll Created Tue 1 Nov 2016 2:21AM
Time to sign the new petition! Closed Tue 1 Nov 2016 3:02PM
Okay, we're public! Spread the word far and wide. Here's a tweet to RT: https://twitter.com/internetowners/status/793464419518865409
You voted on it (or had a chance to). This week we're re-launching the #WeAreTwitter petition with help and support from Shareable and Change.org. We need to start seeding the petition with our names before it goes public. Please sign your names here:
https://www.change.org/p/twitter-inc-free-twitter-from-wall-street
Don't start spreading this to your networks until Tuesday morning.
Results
| Results | Option | % of points | Voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
Agree | 83.3% | 5 |
|
| Abstain | 0.0% | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 16.7% | 1 |
|
|
| Block | 0.0% | 0 | ||
| Undecided | 0% | 243 |
|
6 of 249 people have participated (2%)
Nathan Schneider
Tue 1 Nov 2016 2:39AM
Did it!
Michael Siepmann
Tue 1 Nov 2016 3:05AM
Done.
Bernardo Parrella
Tue 1 Nov 2016 4:15AM
just signed
Billy K.
Tue 1 Nov 2016 11:02AM
Who exactly is the addressee of the petition? What I want to say is that a petition does not affect at all on private company. Petitions are commonly addressed to governmental administrations.
Timothy A McDonald
Tue 1 Nov 2016 1:48PM
Done.
Nathan Schneider Tue 1 Nov 2016 1:21PM
@billyk if you look at the petitions on major sites, including Change.org, you'll see many are addressed to non-state actors. A petition like this only has an effect based on its performative impact, so there's no reason it would affect a state any more than a company. And a company could be quite affected by it, actually, if the company finds it embarrassing or a manifestation of concern by users.
Johnny Haeusler · Sun 30 Oct 2016 11:13AM
@katharinasimon Indiego is for crowdfunding in the first place and betterplace isn't international enough. change.org is a little controversial, but they have the largest community and operate worldwide. If we think about countries like Turkey that we haven't reached out for yet, change.org could help the most.